N.J. owns stock in 2
toll-road firms
Companies could bid on state
highway lease
May 22, 2007
BY JOE DONOHUE
Star-Ledger Staff
New Jersey officials confirmed
yesterday that the state's pension fund
owns nearly 32 million shares of stock,
worth $190 million, in two foreign firms
that operate the Indiana Toll Road and
would be likely bidders if Gov. Jon
Corzine decides to lease the New Jersey
Turnpike or other state highways.
Tom Vincz, spokesman for the state
Treasury Department, said the state owns
25.6 million shares, valued at $82
million, in Macquarie Infrastructure
Co., an Australian firm, and 6.2 million
shares, worth $108 million, in Cintra
Concessiones de Infraestructuras de
Transporte, a Spanish company.
The two companies jointly paid Indiana
$3.8 billion last year to operate that
state's major highway for 75 years, and
paid Chicago $1.8 billion in 2005 to
operate the Skyway for 99 years. The
consortium runs toll roads in other
nations as well.
The two firms would be possible
bidders if Corzine decides to lease
state toll roads to private operators.
Vincz refused to speculate on whether
the state would sell its stock in the
two firms if that happens to avoid the
appearance of a conflict of interest. On
the other hand, if the state rejects
private operation, it could hurt the
value of the stocks.
Within days, Corzine will be
receiving detailed briefings by
Treasurer Bradley Abelow and
Transportation Commissioner Kris Kolluri on the state's options for
converting its assets into cash. Before
the end of June, the governor is expected to discuss those options
publicly.
In his February budget address, the
governor said "monetizing" as sets
through sales or other deals may be the
best alternative for reducing state debt
and freeing up state dollars for other
long-term investments. The other options
include higher taxes, devastating cuts
or even heavier borrowing, he said.
Any plan to "monetize" state assets
would need legislative approval.
Vincz said the state Division of
Investments first began buying Macquarie
stock in November 2003 and Cintra stock
in October 2004. He said the shares are
just a fraction of the pension funds'
overall value of $80 billion. "It's a
small portion and there are various
rationales for stock holdings and stock
decisions that are executed probably on
an hour-by-hour basis," he said.
He added that the State Investment
Council held discussions last week about
direct ownership of toll roads and other
infrastructure, in addition to owning
stocks of operating firms. A consultant
urged the council to consider such
investments because they provide steady
returns that can offset inflation, a
major concern for institutional
investors like the state pension fund.
Across the Delaware yesterday,
Pennsylvania officials concluded that
leasing their turnpike to private
operators would generate the biggest
windfall among three options being
considered.
"The lease option would almost
certainly provide the most money and,
for that reason, we have to take it
seriously," Gov. Ed Rendell said in a
prepared statement.
Rendell had asked Morgan Stanley to
study three options: a long-term lease
of the 537-mile Pennsylvania Turnpike
like Indiana's, creation of a new
tax-exempt corporation to manage it, and
continued operation by the Pennsylvania
Turnpike Commission along with higher
tolls and a new "congestion" tax.
While all three plans could deliver
nearly $1 billion per year to in vest in
new state roads and bridges, Morgan
Stanley concluded that the long-term
lease provided the biggest yield for the
state. Even so, Jim Swoyer, a spokesman
for the Pennsylvania Public Interest
Research Group, called the possibility
"very troubling" and said "privatization
could have serious effects on the public
well into the next century."
|