HEMPSTEAD
(1/22/2008)
—
Some attendees at Tuesday night's town hall meeting in Hempstead
were forced to park a quarter-mile from the meeting and walk
while countless others were turned away. Before the first
question was asked the narrow dead end road leading to the hall
was choked with vehicles that had no place to go and could only
see the flashing emergency lights of a police vehicle ahead.
Citizens like Sara Barnett who arrived in Hempstead with her 88
year old mother found they could not get to the meeting hall.
They and others lost their opportunity to attend, ask their
questions, or hear the discussion.
Those 800 or more
who did make it into the hall heard largely defensive and
argumentative 'answers' to their questions, particularly from
Transportation Commissioner Ted Houghton of El Paso. Reinforcing
the concern of many that these town hall meetings would be
nothing more than a sales pitch, Houghton called it a return to
"Marketing 101." "We did a pretty horrible job with public
relations," admitted Houghton.
David Stall of
CorridorWatch.org says, "Houghton completely misses the concept
of involving the public in the decision making process." "He
came to Hempstead to defend the Commission's decisions and not
to discuss the issues," Stall said.
Often talking over
citizens at the microphone Houghton appeared driven and at times
agitated by the questions being asked.
When asked about
NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement) and the need for
TTC-69 to move containers from Mexico Houghton answered, "[it's]
not about cargo and containers" then summarily cut the citizen
off by abruptly saying, "next question." Houghton took and
defended the position that TTC-69 is not and would not be a
NAFTA highway. Later in the evening another citizen asked
Houghton "why is it not part of NAFTA?" Houghton's answer, "It
doesn't connect to Mexico," caused the room to erupt with
astonished laughter. The man at the microphone told Houghton
that the map that he had shows TTC-69 going to Brownsville.
Houghton quickly responded that it stops in the city of
Brownsville or stops in the city of McAllen which prompted the
citizen speaker to retort, "that's pretty close to Mexico." A
chastising Houghton replied, "Well it's close, but it doesn't,
so lets get the facts right."
[
Stall called the
NAFTA exchange a classic example of how the Commission and TxDOT
are intentionally distorting information to mislead the public
and their elected officials. "They are playing word games that
come dangerously close to outright lies," said Stall. He says
that more important than whether TTC-69 will be a NAFTA highway
or not, is that the discussion be honest. "Apparently they are
willing to tell us anything to keep the public from being
involved and raising their concerns," said Stall. He points out
that numerous TxDOT documents, including materials handed out by
TxDOT in Hempstead during the meeting, make open reference to
TTC-69 moving goods from Mexico. "What good are public forums
with TxDOT if you can't trust them to give honest answers?," he
asked.
One need not
speculate on whether or not the decision to build TTC-69 has
been made, Houghton was quite clear that it would be built. The
only decision he left open for discussion was how to pay for it
saying, "[the] choice is private sector or gas tax." Even that
wasn't really left much in doubt since TxDOT told the audience
that they were moving forward to reach agreement with a private
partner to develop TTC-69.
[Video courtesy of
Citizens for a Better Waller County]